A regular meeting of the Board of Governors of the State Bar of Nevada was
convened by President John H. Mowbray on May 8, 2002, at 9:40 a.m. in the
Washoe B & C Rooms of Harrah's in Reno, Nevada.
The following members of the Board of Governors were in attendance:
John H. Mowbray . . . . . President
Gloria J. Sturman . . . . . President-Elect
N. Patrick Flanagan III . . . . . Vice President
Nancy L. Allf
Bruce T. Beesley
Vincent A. Consul
Michael D. Davidson
Kathleen J. England
Dara J. Goldsmith
Rew R. Goodenow
Ann Price McCarthy
Bridget Robb Peck
John P. Schlegelmilch
William C. Turner
Steven B. Wolfson
STATE BAR
STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT:
Allen W. Kimbrough
Rob Bare
Christopher T. Boadt
Patrice Eichman
Marla Hockfeld
Marc Mersol
GUESTS:
John Bartlett
James Bradshaw
Tom Brooker
David Dahan (by telephone)
Joel Santos
Richard Trachok (by telephone)
1. CALL
TO ORDER AND INTRODUCTIONS
The President called the meeting to order at 9:40 a.m. and welcomed the
members of the Board to Reno. Mr. Mowbray acknowledged Vice President
Patrick Flanagan's attendance.
2.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF PRIOR MEETINGS OF BOARD OF GOVERNORS
The amended minutes of the meeting of the Board of Governors on February 8,
2002, were further amended to correctly reflect the participation (with
disclaimer) of Mr. Wolfson in the discussions and vote regarding the
appointment of the member of the Judicial Selection Commission.
The minutes
of the meeting of the Board held on March 20, 2002 were amended to reflect
Ms. Allf's abstention from approval of the minutes of February 8 in
paragraph 2 thereof and to delete the reference to the American Association
of Matrimonial Attorneys from paragraph 19.
3.
REPORT OF CONTROLLER
Controller Marc Mersol presented his report of the financial condition of
the State Bar as of March 31, 2002, and responded to questions from the
Board.
4.
CONSIDER REPORT OF AUDIT COMMITTEE
The Audit Committee presented the audited financial statements of the State
Bar as of December 31, 2001. Tom Brooker of Kafoury Armstrong & Co., partner
in charge of the audit, was present to explain the findings of the auditors
and to respond to questions. Upon motion made and seconded, the audit was
accepted by the Board unanimously.
5.
CONSIDER MATTERS RELATED TO BOARD OF BAR EXAMINERS
Richard Trachok, Chair of the Board of Bar Examiners (BBX), was present via
telephone to report to the Board on matters of mutual interest. The Supreme
Court having clarified the terms of the members of the BBX, it was noted
that the next appointment to be made by the Board would occur in October
2003.
Mr. Trachok also discussed with the Board the Court's express desire to have
a February bar examination in place by 2004. He requested that the BBX and
the Board form a small joint task force to examine how this could be
appropriately accomplished. The Board approved the formation of the task
force and named President-Elect Sturman as its representative. Mr. Trachok
will represent the BBX, and staff support will be provided by Director of
Admissions Patrice Eichman and the Executive Director.
6.
CONSIDER REPORT OF MEMBER SERVICES COMMITTEE
Mike Davidson, Chair of the Member Services Committee, reported on the
current status of group health insurance plans to be offered to members of
the State Bar. David Dahan, a principal of Orgill-Singer, participated by
telephone and explained the nature of the plans proposed by Anthem Blue
Cross, which would be co-brokered by Orgill-Singer of Las Vegas and Scott
Kulla of Reno.
Mr. Dahan
responded to questions from the Board on these arrangements. The Board
approved the following: (1) the designation of Orgill-Singer and Scott Kulla
as brokers for the State Bar-endorsed plan, and (2) the approval of Anthem
Blue Cross as the insurance carrier.
The most
recent proposal from Lexis-Nexis for a global relationship with the State
Bar was considered. Ms. McCarthy, Chair of the Family Law Section, objected
to portions of the Agreement which could limit the ability of the Section to
obtain sponsorships from other vendors for its programming. Several motions
related to this matter failed for lack of a second. A motion made and
seconded to approve the Agreement and authorizing the Executive Director to
negotiate the most favorable arrangement for the Family Law Section failed
on a divided vote. Subsequently, a motion made and seconded to approve the
Agreement provided that the language of Section 3.4 thereof was mirrored in
Section 3.7 (pertaining to the Section) and permitting the Executive
Director to reduce the amount of compensation if necessary was approved on a
divided vote.
7.
REPORT OF PUBLICATIONS COMMITTEE
John Bartlett, Chair of the Publications Committee, appeared before the
Board to report on the work of his committee and to respond to questions and
comments from the Board. Several suggestions aimed at improving the look and
content of Nevada Lawyer were given by members of the Board to Mr. Bartlett
and Director of Communications Marla Hockfeld.
8.
CONSIDER APPOINTMENT OF CHAIR OF PROBATE AND TRUST SECTION
The selection of John E. Dawson as Chair of the Probate and Trust Section
was ratified by the Board.
9.
CONSIDER MATTERS RELATED TO ACCESS TO JUSTICE COMMITTEE
The Board appointed Rebecca Rivenbark of Reno and Joseph L. Ward of Carson
City as members of the Access to Justice Committee.
The proposed
Pro Bono Survey form was approved, but Mr. Goodenow, Board Liaison to the
Committee was requested to consider certain revisions to the Survey form
prior to its being distributed (by blast facsimile) to the members of the
State Bar.
10.
CONSIDER APPOINTMENT OF STATE BAR DELEGATE TO ABA HOUSE OF DELEGATES
Margo Piscevich of Reno was reappointed as the State Bar's delegate to the
American Bar Association House of Delegates for a two-year term commencing
at the adjournment of the ABA Annual Meeting in 2002.
11.
EMPLOYEE RECOGNITION
Bar Counsel Rob Bare acknowledged the contributions of legal assistant
Jacquie Belmont, who is retiring on June 1, and presented Ms. Belmont with a
gift. The Board joined in thanking Ms. Belmont for her years of service to
the State Bar, and Ms. Belmont responded with her appreciation for her time
at the State Bar and its leadership.
11.
REPORT OF NORTHERN NEVADA DISCIPLINARY BOARD
James Bradshaw of Reno, Chair of the Northern Nevada Disciplinary Board,
reported on the work of his group, as well as expressing a need for better
education in ethics for younger lawyers. Mr. Bradshaw suggested that the
State Bar might want to consider providing sample engagement letters online
and offering additional law practice management courses for CLE credit.
12.
REPORT OF YOUNG LAWYERS SECTION
Joel Santos of Reno, Chair of the Young Lawyers Section of the State Bar,
presented his report to the Board. He noted successful Law Week-related
events, including Law Suits Day, a golf tournament (benefitting the
Make-A-Wish Foundation), Race Judicata, and poster and essay contests. He
stated that new members of the YLS Executive Council were currently being
sought. He also reported on his efforts to arrange for the canvassing boards
required by SCR 84(6) to oversee the counting of the ballots from the Board
of Governors election.
13.
CONSIDER SUPREME COURT RULE GOVERNING COMPOSITION OF BOARD OF GOVERNORS
The Executive Director discussed with the Board the current discrepancy that
exists between SCR 81 and Board Bylaws Section 3.2 as it affects the
composition of the Board in general and in particular the division of seats
between Clark and Washoe Counties (Districts 1 and 4). Mr. Kimbrough
presented his analysis of the distribution of the attorney population
between the two subject districts and recommended that the Board seek to
amend SCR 81 to reflect nine (9) members from District 1 and four (4)
members from District 4. On motion made and seconded, the Board approved
this recommendation.
On motion
made and seconded, the Board approved a reconsideration of the prior vote
and postponed consideration of the matter to the June 12 meeting of the
Board. Mr. Goodenow, Mr. Schlegelmilch, and Mr. Kimbrough were requested to
review this matter and provide additional information to the Board at that
time.
14.
REPORT ON BOARD OF GOVERNORS ELECTION
The Executive Director reported on the status of the on-going election for
members of the Board of Governors from Districts 1 and 4. He expressed his
concern at the cost of the State Bar's policy of providing a blast facsimile
for each candidate. The Board discussed other potential means for allowing
candidates access to the membership (e.g., providing a forum in Nevada
Lawyer). Upon motion made and seconded, the Board directed the staff to
cease the blast fax program beginning with the 2003 election.
15.
CONSIDER REVISIONS TO SUPREME COURT RULE 79 (ADDRESS OF MEMBER)
The President expressed to the Board his concerns regarding the failure of
members to timely notify the State Bar following a change of address. The
Board concurred that strengthening SCR 79 would be appropriate (by a divided
vote) and instructed Bar Counsel to prepare a Petition to the Supreme Court
to implement a thirty-day deadline for notification and adding a fine for
failure to timely notify.
16. REPORT OF STANDING COMMITTEE ON ETHICS AND PROFESSIONAL
RESPONSIBILITY
The Board considered the written quarterly report of Marshal S. Willick,
Chair of the Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility.
17.
CONSIDER MATTERS RELATED TO FEE DISPUTE ARBITRATION COMMITTEE
The Board of Governors appointed Alan Sachs as an attorney member of the Fee
Dispute Arbitration Committee (Las Vegas Panel A) and Kevin Kirkendall and
Robert M. Shaw as lay members of Las Vegas Panel A. The request to appoint
Vera McCauley was deferred to a subsequent meeting of the Board.
Ms. Peck
reported on the issue of potential rules requiring mandatory participation
in the fee dispute process at the risk of disciplinary action. She stated
that further study was needed and that it was hoped that a rough draft of
the requisite revisions to the Fee Dispute bylaws and rules may be submitted
at the June 12 meeting of the Board.
18.
REPORT OF CONTINUING LEGAL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Christopher Boadt, Director of the Continuing Legal Education Department,
reported to the Board on various issues, including the 2002 Annual Meeting
in Hawaii and the dinner and video honoring retiring Justice Cliff Young.
President Mowbray urged the Board members to assist in obtaining financial
support for the Annual Meeting. Mr. Boadt also discussed issues regarding
Annual Meeting policies concerning guest registrations.
19.
RECONSIDER ABA CAMPAIGN TO SAVE THE STATE JUSTICE INSTITUTE
Upon reconsideration and a report from Mr. Goodenow regarding the potential
impact on the National Judicial College, the Board voted to support a
resolution to Congress setting forth the State Bar's objections to cuts in
funding for the SJI and authorized the President to execute same.
20.
CONSIDER MATTERS RELATED TO 75th ANNIVERSARY OF THE STATE BAR
President-Elect Sturman presented her initial ideas for the celebration of
the 75th Anniversary of the State Bar (the "Diamond Jubilee"), which will
occur in January, 2003. She requested and received the Board's approval to
appoint an ad hoc committee to plan and carry out the events involved.
The Board approved a budget amendment in the amount of $2500 to fund the
work of the Diamond Jubilee Committee.
21.
REPORT OF BAR COUNSEL
Bar Counsel Rob Bare reported on various litigation matters of public record
involving the State Bar, including the Ninth Circuit's denial of hearing en
banc in the Gardner matter and the enjoining of a lawyer referral service in
Reno.
22.
REPORT OF EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Executive Director Allen Kimbrough gave an oral report to the Board in
supplementation of his written report. He discussed with the Board the need
for the appointment of the canvassing boards required by SCR 82(6) in
connection with the election of the Board of Governors. The Board delegated
to the President the power to appoint the two canvassing boards, one for
District 1 and one for District 4.
23.
INFORMATIONAL ITEMS
Various matters were reviewed, including the scheduled commencement of the
Boyd School of Law, mandatory malpractice issues, and statistics from the
American Bar Association on state bar membership.
24.
CONSIDER MATTERS RELATED TO LAWYER REFERRAL AND INFORMATION SERVICE
The President expressed his concerns to the Board regarding the current
posture of the Lawyer Referral and Information Service ("LRIS") Committee,
including his attendance at the May 2 meeting of the LRIS Committee and the
recent consultation provided by the ABA regarding the operation of the
service. The LRIS Committee had requested clarification of its role with
respect to oversight of the LRIS and the distribution of the net revenues
generated (the State Bar Restricted Fund). A task force consisting of Ms.
Sturman, Mr. Consul, Ms. Peck, and Mr. Wolfson (and Ms. Goldsmith as Board
liaison) was appointed to review this situation and report back to the Board
at its June 12 meeting.
The Board
appointed Susan Sherrod of Las Vegas to a two-year term as a member of the
LRIS Committee.
25. REPORT OF PRESIDENT
The President reported to the Board on the recent rural Nevada tour
undertaken by Mr. Mowbray, President-Elect Sturman, and the Executive
Director. He shared with the Board some of the concerns of our rural members
regarding bar services and access to justice issues.
26.
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned at 3:10 p.m.
Respectfully
submitted,
John H.
Mowbray
President
Allen W.
Kimbrough
Executive Director