A regular
meeting of the Board of Governors of the State Bar of Nevada was convened by
President John H. Mowbray on October 17, 2001, at 9:00 a.m. in the
California Room of the Eldorado Hotel and Casino in Reno, Nevada.
The following members of the Board of Governors were in attendance:
John H. Mowbray . . . . . President
Gloria J. Sturman . . . . . President-Elect
Nancy L. Allf
Bruce T. Beesley
Vincent A. Consul
Kathleen J. England
Dara J. Goldsmith
Rew R. Goodenow
Ann Price McCarthy
Bridget Robb Peck
John P. Schlegelmilch
Steven B. Wolfson
Dean Richard Morgan, Ex Officio
STATE BAR STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT:
Allen Kimbrough
Rob Bare
Christopher Boadt
Patrice Eichman
Marc Mersol
Audrey Bath
GUESTS:
Joel Santos
Marshal Willick
Richard Trachok
Thomas R. C. (Spike) Wilson II
David Amesbury
Stephen V. Novacek
Vernon E. Leverty
1. CALL TO ORDER
The President led the Board in a moment of silence in honor of Vice
President Patrick Flanagan who is recuperating from an accident and
expressed the Board=s best wishes for his recovery and speedy return to
meetings of the Board.
2. APPROVAL
OF THE MINUTES OF THE JUNE 28 AND AUGUST 17, 2001 MEETINGS OF THE BOARD OF
GOVERNORS
The minutes of the August 17, 2001 meeting of the Board of Governors and the
Revised Minutes of the June 28, 2001 meeting of the Board of Governors were
approved unanimously.
3. CONSIDER
APPOINTMENTS TO PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY AND CONDUCT COMMITTEE AND REPORT
OF COMMITTEE
Marshal Willick, Chair of the Standing Committee on Professional
Responsibility and Conduct, appeared and shared with the Board the currently
dormant status of the Committee and his goals for its revitalization,
including the addition of new committee members. The Board agreed to assist
in these revitalization efforts. Sam Stone, Richard I. Dreitzer and Michael
J. Warhola were appointed to fill three vacancies on the Committee. The
Board expressed its appreciation to Mr. Willick for his service.
4. REPORT OF ADMISSIONS DEPARTMENT
The Board was joined by Richard Trachok, Chair of the Nevada Board of Bar
Examiners. Mr. Trachok, Director of Admissions Patrice Eichman, and the
Board engaged in a review of the 2001 Bar Examination, including the pass
rate and the regrade process. Discussion was had regarding a desire to
administer the Bar Examination more than once a year and the requisite
increase in staffing required to accomplish such a goal.
Upon motion made and seconded, the Board determined (on a divided vote) to
advise the Supreme Court that the Board was in favor of retaining the
current procedure of regrading examinations falling between a score of 74.5
and 75.5.
The President thanked Mr. Trachok, the Board of Bar Examiners, and its
related committees for their extraordinary service to the Bar.
Mr. Trachok presented Board Member Kathleen England with an award in
recognition of her many years of service as Chair of the Moral Character and
Fitness Committee.
Bar Counsel was asked to investigate whether there were any studies or other
information available showing a correlation between performance on a bar
examination and disciplinary actions.
Dean Morgan responded to questions regarding the fields of study of
graduates of the Boyd School of Law in comparison to their passing rates on
the 2001 Bar Examination.
5. REPORT OF THE MEMBER SERVICES COMMITTEE
Mike Davidson, Chair of the Member Services Committee, reported to the Board
that the Committee continues to seek a new health care insurer and is
presently evaluating group plans. The Committee is working with a broker,
but no formal agreement has been suggested at this time.
The Committee=s recommendation that the State Bar contract with
LegalStaff.com for the creation of a career center on the Bar=s website was
approved unanimously.
The Executive Director reported that negotiations were ongoing with
LEXIS-NEXIS regarding a global sponsorship arrangement.
6. REPORT OF COMMISSION ON MULTIJURISDICTIONAL PRACTICE
Thomas R. C. (Spike) Wilson II, Chair of the Supreme Court Commission on
Multijurisdictional Practice (AMJP@), appeared before the Board of Governors
to present a status report. He advised that three public hearings had been
held in September and early October in Elko, Las Vegas and Reno, and that
there was significant input and participation. Mr. Wilson stated that two
additional meetings of the Commission would be held on October 24 and
November 15, and that the final report of the Commission will be delivered
to the Supreme Court prior to December 1.
7. CONSIDER REVISIONS TO FAMILY LAW SECTION BYLAWS
Board Member Ann Price McCarthy, Chair of the Family Law Section, requested
approval of certain amendments to the Bylaws of the Section. Having
corrected a typographical error in Section 4.1 thereof, the Board
unanimously approved the Bylaws as amended.
8. CONSIDER FUNDING REQUEST FROM CLIENT SECURITY FUND COMMITTEE
David Amesbury, Chair, and members Steve Novacek and Gene Leverty of the
Client Security Fund Committee met with the Board to discuss the current
status of the Fund and the need for additional funds in order to satisfy
current extraordinary claims. The Committee members reviewed written
materials previously provided to the Board concerning the level of
contributions to the Fund in Nevada versus other jurisdictions and the
current policies regarding the payment of claims in our state.
The Board and Bar Counsel commented on the importance of this Committee and
its role in reassuring members of the public in situations of defalcation,
while recognizing that the work of the Committee and the uses of the Fund
are not well known by the general membership of the State Bar. It was also
recognized that the Committee should be encouraged to pursue claims against
the miscreants or their estates in order to recoup claims paid from the
Fund.
The President requested that Board Member Dara Goldsmith (a former member of
the Committee) review the Committee=s Bylaws in an effort to clarify its
powers and responsibilities. The Budget Committee was asked to review the
financial issues related to the Fund=s need for additional resources.
9. REPORT OF YOUNG LAWYERS SECTION
Joel Santos, Chair of the Young Lawyers Section of the State Bar appeared
before the Board and gave a report on the recent and upcoming activities of
the Section. Mr. Santos advised that the Executive Council of the Section
had selected Elizabeth Whitney of Reno as Chair-Elect and Henna Rasul of
Carson City as a District Representative on the Executive Council. The Board
unanimously ratified these appointments.
10. CONSIDER APPOINTMENTS AND ADJUSTMENTS TO NORTHERN AND SOUTHERN NEVADA
DISCIPLINARY BOARDS
The Board made the following appointments for one-year terms: Richard Pocker
as Chair and Daniel Albregts as Vice Chair of the Southern Nevada
Disciplinary Board and James Bradshaw as Chair of the Northern Nevada
Disciplinary Board.
The Board unanimously voted to transfer Southern Nevada Disciplinary Board
member Rusty Jardine to the Northern Nevada Disciplinary Board at his
request. Mr. Jardine=s term will expire in October, 2002.
Northern Nevada Disciplinary Board alternate attorney member JoLee Wickes
was re-designated to full attorney member status on that Disciplinary Board.
11. CONSIDER REAPPOINTMENTS TO THE CONTINUING LEGAL EDUCATION COMMITTEE
The following members of the Continuing Legal Education Committee were
unanimously reappointed by the Board for an additional three-year term: John
Albrecht, William Brunson, Bryan Clark, Elana Hatch, Jenny Hubach and Cookie
Olshein. Board Member John Schlegelmilch dissented from this vote.
12. CONSIDER APPOINTMENT OF MEMBER OF CONTINUING LEGAL EDUCATION COMMITTEE
(PLANNING TEAM B)
The Board appointed David Neidert of Reno to fill the vacancy on planning
team B of the CLE Committee.
13. CONSIDER APPOINTMENT OF EX-OFFICIO MEMBER OF THE CONTINUING LEGAL
EDUCATION COMMITTEE
Mace Yampolsky was unanimously appointed as an ex-officio member of the CLE
Committee. The Director of Continuing Legal Education was requested to
revise the Bylaws of the CLE Committee to reflect the ex-officio status of
such members.
14. REPORT OF THE CONTINUING LEGAL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Christopher Boadt, Director of Continuing Legal Education, reported on the
recent activities of his department, including financial results for the
year to date and new publications.
Mr. Boadt presented a draft budget to the Board for the 2002 Annual Meeting
of the State Bar in Hawaii. The Board unanimously approved the draft budget.
Mr. Boadt and the Executive Director also recommended reimbursement policies
and procedures for the 2002 Annual Meeting covering the payment of travel
expenses for Board members, staff members, speakers, sections and
committees. The Board unanimously adopted the recommendations of the staff
with respect to these matters.
15. REPORT OF CONTROLLER
The Executive Director presented the Financial Reports of the State Bar as
of August 31 and September 30, 2001, and responded to questions from the
Board regarding same.
16. REPORT OF BAR COUNSEL
Bar Counsel Rob Bare appeared before the Board and reported on the
activities of his department.
Action on new SCR 106.5 (relating to Lawyers Concerned for Lawyers) was
deferred to the December 7 meeting of the Board and Mr. Bare was asked to
make further revisions to the proposed rule.
Mr. Bare reviewed with the Board the most recent Statistical Report and
noted changes occurring since it was prepared.
Mr. Bare reported on pending litigation in general terms and no privileged
matters were discussed.
Having noted that proposed revisions to SCR 199 (Firm names) had been
referred to the Supreme Court Commission on MJP, the Executive Director was
asked to communicate to the Commission the position of the Board taken at
the August 17, 2001, meeting in Minden in support of the adoption of ABA
Model Rule 7.5 in lieu of the current SCR 199.
17. REPORT OF EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Executive Director Allen Kimbrough advised the Board regarding recent events
at the State Bar, including the retirement of the mortgage on the State Bar
headquarters in Las Vegas. Mr. Kimbrough advised the Board that a fee
suspension order would be issued immediately for those with unpaid 2001 bar
dues. Mr. Kimbrough further reported on the preliminary discussions between
the State Bar and the Center for Law Related Education in which an increased
role of the State Bar in such efforts was being discussed.
18. REPORT OF PRESIDENT
Mr. Mowbray expressed his appreciation to the members of the Supreme Court
Commission on MJP and especially its Chair, Thomas R. C. Wilson II, for the
expeditious manner in which the Commission=s charge was being fulfilled.
19. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned at 2:38 p.m.Respectfully submitted,
John H. Mowbray Allen W. Kimbrough
President Executive Director