A regular
meeting of the Board of Governors of the State Bar of Nevada was convened by
President John H. Mowbray on December 7, 2001, at 9:40 a.m. in the Board
Room of the State Bar of Nevada in Las Vegas, Nevada.
The following members of the Board of Governors were in attendance:
John H. Mowbray . . . . . President
Gloria J. Sturman . . . . . President-Elect
Daniel P. Polsenberg . . . . Immediate Past President
Nancy L. Allf
Bruce T. Beesley
Vincent A. Consul
Michael D. Davidson
Kathleen J. England
Dara J. Goldsmith
Rew R. Goodenow
Bridget Robb Peck
John Paul Schlegelmilch (by telephone)
William C. Turner
Steven B. Wolfson
STATE BAR
STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT:
Allen W. Kimbrough
Rob Bare
Marla Hockfeld
Marc Mersol
Audrey Bath
Georgia Taylor
GUESTS:
Luke Puschnig
David Amesbury
1. CALL TO ORDER
The President welcomed the Board members and guests. Dan Polsenberg led a
prayer for Vice President Pat Flanagan, who is recuperating from an
accident.
2.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF OCTOBER 17, 2001 MEETING OF THE BOARD OF
GOVERNORS
The minutes of the October 17, 2001 meeting of the Board of Governors were
approved unanimously.
3.
REPORT OF CONTROLLER
The Controller presented the Financial Statements of the State Bar as of
October 31, 2001 and reviewed them with the Board.
The Board
authorized the Executive Director and the Controller to execute all
necessary documents to establish the $300,000 line of credit for the State
Bar at BankWest of Nevada previously discussed and approved. Any draws on
the line of credit would require the approval of the Operations Committee.
The Board
ratified the action of the Operations Committee on November 29, 2001,
approving banking resolutions for the State Bar's account at Bank of
America.
4.
CONSIDER APPROVAL OF 2002 OPERATING BUDGET
Having been approved by the Budget Committee at its meeting on November 29,
2001, the proposed 2002 Operating Budget for the State Bar of Nevada was
presented to the Board by Steve Wolfson, Chair of the Budget Committee, and
by Marc Mersol, Controller. Mr. Mersol reviewed the various provisions of
the Budget with members of the Board, noting that the 2002 Budget projected
a positive cash flow of $166,415. The 2002 Budget as proposed also includes
a 2.5% cost-of-living adjustment for staff salaries (previously approved by
the Compensation and Personnel Committee). Upon motion made and seconded the
2002 Operating Budget was approved unanimously. The Board expressed its
appreciation to the Budget Committee and to Mr. Mersol for their efforts and
presentation.
5.
CONSIDER LAWYER REFERRAL AND INFORMATION SERVICE RESTRICTED REVENUES AND
TRANSFERS
The Board approved the transfer of the LRIS fund balance at December 31,
2000 of $24,702 from the unrestricted fund balance to the LRIS Restricted
Fund, which may be used only for the operation of the LRIS Department or for
other permissible projects.
From the LRIS
Restricted Fund, the Board of Governors unanimously made the following
allocations to the unrestricted fund balance:
< $17,000 for the purchase of new LRIS software;
< $18,000 to fund the anticipated part-time Coordinator of Law Related
Education; and
< Up to $25,000 for hardware and software required to bring the State Bar
website "in house."
6. CONSIDER LAW RELATED EDUCATION PROGRAM
The President provided the Board with background information regarding the
history of law related education in Nevada, and the expressed desire of the
Nevada Center for Law Related Education to have its duties and
responsibilities assumed by the State Bar. The Executive Director further
reviewed with the Board his written comments on this subject.
Following a
discussion the Board voted to approve the following:
< Creation of the part-time position of Coordinator of Law Related Education
as an employee of the State Bar (to be funded as approved in Item 5 above);
< Authorization for the President and the Executive Director to conclude
negotiations with the Nevada Center for Law Related Education for the
assumption of its duties, responsibilities and funds; and
< Creation of the State Bar Committee on Law Related Education (to be
appointed by the President).
7.
CONSIDER REVISIONS TO FEE DISPUTE ARBITRATION COMMITTEE BYLAWS
Luke Puschnig, Regional Chair of the Fee Dispute Arbitration Committee
appeared before the Board to discuss pending issues and to present revisions
to the current Bylaws of the Committee for the Board's consideration.
The Board
engaged in an extensive discussion with Mr. Puschnig regarding various
matters related to the work of the Committee, which is governed by SCR
86(12). Consideration was given to possibly requesting the Supreme Court to
amend such rule to provide for mandatory participation in the arbitration
process under threat of discipline, but the consensus was to defer further
discussion of this topic to the January meeting of the Board. Mr. Bare was
requested to gather information on this topic.
With respect
to the proposed Bylaws, the following amendments were proposed by the Board:
-To delete from Section A(2) the words "and no person shall serve more than
three (3) consecutive terms"; and
-To delete Section C(6) in its entirety.
Upon motion
made and seconded, the proposed Bylaws (as amended) were approved.
8.
CONSIDER APPOINTMENT TO FEE DISPUTE ARBITRATION COMMITTEE
The Board appointed Gary C. Milne to Las Vegas Panel A of the Fee Dispute
Arbitration Committee.
9.
MEMBER SERVICES
The Board considered the ABA Members Retirement Program's June 2001 Progress
Report. The Executive Director reported to the Board on the status of
negotiations with Lexis-Nexis and the pursuit of group health insurance for
Bar members.
10.
CONSIDER ADJUSTMENTS TO NORTHERN AND SOUTHERN NEVADA DISCIPLINARY BOARDS
The Board approved changing the status of the Southern Nevada Disciplinary
Board members Bruce Leslie and Howard Miller from Alternate Attorney Members
to Attorney Members.
The Board
discussed its desire to receive periodic reports from the two Disciplinary
Boards and requested that Richard Pocker, Southern Nevada Regional Chair,
appear at the March meeting of the Board. Members of the Board further
requested that efforts be made to recruit new members of the Disciplinary
Board, particularly persons of color.
11.
CONSIDER APPOINTMENTS TO STANDING COMMITTEE ON JUDICIAL ETHICS AND ELECTION
PRACTICES
The Board approved (with Mr. Wolfson abstaining) the reappointment of the
following members of the Standing Committee on Judicial Ethics and Election
Practices: C. Stanley Hunterton, R. Gardner Jolley, Thomas E. Perkins,
Thomas R. Sheets and Steven Wolfson. Additionally, the Board appointed
Kathleen M. Paustian as a member of the Committee, replacing the late John
McCune.
12.
CONSIDER APPOINTMENTS TO STANDING COMMITTEE ON PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY
AND CONDUCT
Dennis Kennedy, Jeffrey Stempel and J. T. Moran III were each appointed to
two-year terms as members of the Standing Committee on Professional
Responsibility and Conduct.
13.
GAMING LAW SECTION
The Board ratified the Executive Committee of the Gaming Law Section's
nominations of Anthony N. Cabot and Keith E. Kizer for reappointment to
three-year terms on the Executive Committee of the Section.
14.
LIAISON APPOINTMENTS
Dara J. Goldsmith was designated as Board liaison to the Elder Law Section;
Bridget Robb Peck was designated as Board liaison to the Bankruptcy Section;
and Kathleen England was designated as the Board's co-liaison to the Young
Lawyers Section (with Vice President Flanagan).
15. LAWYERS CONCERNED FOR LAWYERS
The Board considered the written report of Coe Swobe, Coordinator of the
Lawyers Concerned for Lawyers Program, as well as the report of the ABA
Lawyer Assistance Program review team. Further discussion of this subject
was continued to a subsequent meeting of the Board.
16.
REPORT OF CLE DEPARTMENT
The Board considered the written report of CLE Director Christopher Boadt.
17.
CONSIDER CLIENT SECURITY FUND ISSUES
David Amesbury appeared before the Board to discuss the status of the State
Bar's Client Security Fund, including the potential shortfall of
$5,000-6,000 in order to be able to make payments to 2001 claimants. On
motion made and seconded, the Board approved a budget amendment to increase
the amount to be transferred by the State Bar into the Client Security Fund
in 2001 by $7,500, for a total of $85,500. Mr. Goodenow dissented from this
vote.
The Board
discussed the concerns previously addressed by the Budget Committee and
agreed that there are issues related to the Client Security Fund which merit
further study and action. In particular, the members of the Board expressed
a desire for the Client Security Fund to have a business plan, to more
aggressively seek recovery opportunities or criminal prosecutions, and to
consider avenues for increased funding.
The Board
unanimously approved the formation of a Task Force to be chaired by Dara
Goldsmith to study the situation and make recommendations to the Board for
further action. Other members of the Task Force would include Rew Goodenow,
Steve Wolfson, Bill Turner, David Amesbury, Rob Bare of the State Bar staff,
and such other members as the Chair may deem appropriate.
18. REPORT OF THE COMMUNICATIONS DEPARTMENT
Marla Hockfeld, Director of Communications, appeared before the Board and
reported on the activities of the Communications Department.
19. REPORT OF BAR COUNSEL
The Board approved the proposed ADKT petition regarding new SCR 106.5
pertaining to the Lawyers Concerned for Lawyers program.
Bar Counsel
Rob Bare reviewed the current Discipline Statistical Report with the Board.
20.
REPORT OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Executive Director Allen Kimbrough gave oral comments in supplementation of
his written report to the Board, noting in particular issues regarding the
use of the State Bar office building by outside parties.
21.
REPORT OF PRESIDENT
President John Mowbray reported to the Board regarding the completion of the
work of the Supreme Court Commission on Multijurisdictional Practice, whose
Report with recommendations was filed with the Court 92 days after its
organizational meeting. Mr. Mowbray expressed his appreciation to Commission
Chair Thomas R. C. (Spike) Wilson II, the members of the Commission, and the
Executive Director (who served as Reporter).
22.
EXECUTIVE SESSION
In executive session the Board discussed the annual review of the Executive
Director as conducted by the Operations Committee on November 29, 2001, and
ratified the salary adjustment for the Executive Director recommended by
that Committee.
23. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned at 2:35 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
John H.
Mowbray
President
Allen W.
Kimbrough
Executive Director